A few days ago I wrapped up 3 months of posting to Instagram consistently to see if it would be an effective way to help more trainers and coaches find Bootcamp Ideas.
And now it’s over… have I got a story to tell you!
There were highs, lows and, as happens with content creation, many boring parts.
But, was it all worth it?
Did social media prove to be the business building magic pill that so many guru’s out there tell us it is?
I will reveal all, in the form of a fun adventure book about my Instagram business experiment below.
- Chapter 1: Once Upon A Lack Of New Customers
- Chapter 2: How I Chose Instagram To Focus On
- Chapter 3: Planning My Experiment and Metrics
- Chapter 4: My First Month Posting On Instagram
- Chapter 5: Month Two And Three On Instagram
- Chapter 6: The Numbers
- Chapter 7: The Good Stuff We Can’t Track With Numbers
- Chapter 8: Was The Experiment Worth It? Will I Keep Using Instagram?
- Chapter 9: The Tools I Used To Make Things Easier
- Chapter 10: What’s Next?
- Chapter 11: My Final Thoughts
Chapter 1: Once Upon A Lack Of New Customers
For the last few years I’ve noticed a drop in sales and new member sign ups here on Bootcamp Ideas.
Initially, I thought it was just the effects of COVID. Lot’s of fitness coaches had left the industry, but assumed it would bounce back in time as new people came into the industry.
But it didn’t.
At first I thought it must be what I was selling. So I played around with new offerings and jazzing up old offerings in new ways. I also played around with new email sequences and sales funnels. I spent a lot of time here and even experimented with some sales tactics that I felt uncomfortable using with but told myself ‘Well, that’s just how things are done now.’
While I learned a lot doing all of this, it didn’t really make a big difference to the bottom line.
And that’s when I noticed something.
For years the Bootcamp Ideas newsletter has been my main way of communicating with people. Trainers find my website, like it and then jump on the newsletter to get notified of new material coming out. One thing I didn’t pay too much attention to was the number of people on my newsletter list, I focused on just being consistent instead.
The thing I noticed was… for the first time in years my email list wasn’t growing.
No wonder sales were down. It wasn’t that there was anything wrong with my services or sales process – it was that I simply wasn’t getting in front of new fitness coaches.
Chapter 2: How I Chose Instagram To Focus On
Now I knew I needed to focus on getting Bootcamp Ideas in front of new faces.
For over a decade that has been through Search Engine Optimization (SEO) but when I looked at the data those numbers where down. Trainers just weren’t searching for ‘bootcamp ideas‘ like they used to.
But surely trainers still needed ideas for their classes? So where were they looking for them? Where were they hanging out?
I had a pretty good hunch: Instagram
But I didn’t want to be on Instagram. I didn’t want to create reels and when I used Instagram I would always end up getting sucked into my feed and losing hours of time.
Plus, I wanted new newsletter subscribers. How would that even work on Instagram where you can’t share links in the captions?
Around that time I read an article about a guy who had grown his email list to 200,000 members using mostly LinkedIn. Maybe LinkedIn would be a better option for me? Lot’s of fitness professionals on there too and they’re probably in the mindset of needing resources for their business when they’re on there too.
I also liked that I could just write on LinkedIn. I love writing and find it much faster than creating things on Canva or with video.
So I bought one of his courses and got started. I thought, at the very least I’ll learn something.
And I did.
I learned that I dislike LinkedIn even more than Instagram.
It’s like it’s trying to do too much and just ends up feeling overcrowded. Plus, my posts received very little traction.
Meanwhile, over on Instagram I was getting some traction (the scheduler I was using for my LinkedIn posts had a feature where it posted to Instagram too). So I decided to pivot and focus on Instagram instead.
Chapter 3: Planning My Experiment and Metrics
From the research I had done I knew that in order to see results on any social media platform that I needed to be posting often.
I had also read from several people who grew fast on different platforms that they didn’t just focus on content, but also focused on engaging with people (on their own content and other’s content) in meaningful ways (ie. not just liking a bunch of sh!t but actually starting a conversation).
So this is what I decided on:
- Post something every day – but sit down once a week to create all the content in one go and schedule it out
- Only post ‘flat’ posts which is an Instagram post with a single image and caption
- Once per week share a workout called βWhiteboard Wednesdayβ where I share a trainer’s whiteboard and their workout knowing that my audience like workout ideas
- Treat creating the content like planning a workout and use templates to make them fast
- No reels or videos because I wanted to focus on my existing strength, which is writing. I also wanted to see if it was possible to grow on Instagram without using video or stories.
- Engage with people who like or comment on my stuff by going to their profile and leaving a useful comment or two
- Ultimate Goal: Get people to join my email newsletter (more on how I did this later)
The other thing I kept in mind was this quote from Pat Flynn:
βYou have to be cringe before they binge.β
You only see popular content on social media because β well β itβs popular. There is a lot of not-so-great content out there too. I made a conscious effort not to worry about every post being life-changing and instead to focus on consistency.
Chapter 4: My First Month Posting On Instagram
My first month was probably the best. I had a post blow up with nearly 200 likes (that’s a lot for me) and there was a lot of novelty in doing something new.
I also really enjoyed being able to interact with my readers in a back and forth way. We could chat in the comments of one of my posts. I could go to the profile of someone who liked one of my comments and leave a question or some encouragement on one of their posts.
The newsletter tends to be more of a one way communication tool, with only a few readers replying and no way for me to check out the businesses and fitness classes of those who subscribe.
I did run into my first problem in the first month though.
One week was particularly hectic in my personal life with things on and sick family members and I missed my session to batch and schedule my social media posts. Before I knew it a whole week had passed and I hadn’t posted anything!
After this I changed from 7 posts per week to 4 posts. This way I could schedule almost 2 weeks of content at a time which gave me a bit of breathing space.
I did notice something right away from reducing the number of posts per week and that was that the more you post, the more people you will reach. This is why you see people posting multiple times daily.
What you need to decide if you choose to do something like this is, what’s sustainable for you?
Learning #1: The more frequently you post, the more people you will reach (also, the most ‘viral’ posts you’ll create).
Chapter 5: Month Two And Three On Instagram
In my second month I did something strange.
I deleted Instagram off my phone.
This was part of a digital minimalism month I was doing because I was using my phone way to much. Part of this was due to Instagram but part of it was just some bad habits I had gotten into which I wanted to break.
I figured I could still keep the challenge going without the Instagram app using other tools and at the end of the month, if I needed to, I could reinstall Instagram.
I also thought this was a good test for the experiment. Can you use Instagram to find new customers without even having the app on your phone or access to some of the features that only come with the app?
It turns out you totally can!
The one downside I noticed (other than that it was less convenient at times) was that I found myself engaging with followers less. I had to really make a conscious effort to do this from my computer.
At the end of the month I decided to leave the app off my phone and finish the experiment without it.
Learning #2: You can have a presence on Instagram without the app quite easily. You lose some convenience but make that time back with no doom scrolling.
I also experimented with a different way of getting people onto my email list. In the first month I simply invited people to join via the link in my Instagram bio.
But in the second month, on a whim, I decided to ask them to leave the comment ‘WHITEBOARD’ and told them I’d DM them some workout ideas. I then sent them a link to join my newsletter and get the PDF emailed to them. This worked way better and X of the X I DM’d the link to signed up.
Learning #3: Don’t ask people to leave the app to take action. Get them to leave a comment or send you a DM. You can then send them a link to follow a their leisure.
Chapter 6: The Numbers
Okay, so the moment you’ve been waiting for.
It’s possible you even just skipped straight to this part because you’re a glutton for statistics!
Before I get into the hard numbers though I want to also mention soft metrics. There are important things that can’t be measured with numbers that I’ll discuss in chapter 7.
Followers:
- Gained: 107
- Lost: 89
- Net Follower Gain: 18
- Total Followers: 4,273
If my goal had been to gain new followers, I would have failed miserably. Which I guess goes to show it’s not a great metric to go by. I believe I lost so many followers because my account is quite old and I may no longer be relevant to some of my old followers. Still, it surprised me how few new followers I got.
Engagement
- Total Accounts Reached: 8,752
- Total Accounts Engaged: 613
- Link in bio clicks: 6
These are mostly vanity metrics. Nearly half those stats came from one post. Humour did really well for reaching lots of people. Insightful statements and polls did well for comments. And workout ideas did best for new followers. And as you can see, asking people to click the link in your bio doesn’t really work.
New email subscribers:
- From link in bio: Unsure, but with only 6 clicks…
- 5 workout templates opt-in: 4 (57%)
- Whiteboards opt-in: 1 (50%)
- Dice games opt-in: 1 (50%)
Somewhat stupidly I didn’t look into the tech side of how to track email subscribers coming from Instagram before getting started. I should have set up a special link or tracking system. So these numbers are just what I know for sure, but there may be a few more. Still, 6 email subscribers is pretty low for 3 months work.
Again, one of the big takeaways I have from this is that social media really is a numbers game.
In that it’s a game with numbers that are meaningless outside of the game and that if you can scale up big time, you will see some benefits trickly out the bottom.
With 100,000 followers or thrice daily posting or using reels I know I would have seen better results. But I wanted to do this in a way that I knew would work for my schedule and life.
Chapter 7: The Good Stuff We Can’t Track With Numbers
So while the numbers aren’t anything to get excited about, it’s possible there are things happening that we can’t track.
- Did I build trust with some people by showing up in their feed more often or engaging with them in the comments?
- Are people recognising my name when they get my email? And therefore more likely to open it and read it?
- I’ve learned more about my audiences businesses and what they look like from short chats and seeing their profiles.
These are worth considering but hard to measure.
Chapter 8: Was The Experiment Worth It? Will I Keep Using Instagram?
It’s funny that before I went through the numbers of this experiment, I would have said yes, I will keep going.
In fact, as I was planning my next experiment one of the things I was conflicted about was how to keep Instagram going and run the next experiment when I realistically only have the capacity for one. Going through these numbers takes some pressure off.
I will continue with Instagram, but in a much reduced format. Perhaps 3 posts a fortnight – 1 workout ideas and 2 others.
It’s tempting to keep going. Instagram does a great job of making it FEEL like you’re being successful. It throws all these metrics in your face like ‘engagement’ and ‘reach’. But really, those metrics are only good for Instagram.
That’s why my advice to you is that if you’re using Instagram for business, make sure that you’re being clear about what you want to get out of it. If it’s more clients, make sure you’re getting more clients for all your hard work.
So, why continue at all?
Because I loved engaging with the readers. That was my favourite part by far. Especially when I was being consistent it.
Learning #4: I love engaging with readers. I need to focus more on this than content creation.
I also don’t particular like creating short form content. It often feels like you have to be overly contrarian or black and white to gain traction with it. There is no space for nuance.
Learning #5: I prefer creating long-form content where I can look at all aspects of a topic.
That said, I now have a bunch of short-form content I can re-use. Only a small percentage of your followers sees each post, so I’ll happily re-use my favourite posts in the future to keep content creation low-key.
Chapter 9: The Tools I Used To Make Things Easier
I used 3 tools during the challenge (other than Instagram itself):
- Hypefury: This is actually a Twitter/X growth tool (as I was also posting to Twitter with no results like LinkedIn) but it allows you to post your tweets as neat little images to Instagram too. I found it really easy to schedule out my posts. It does cost a bit, but I got a crazy discount off my first few months. When that’s over I’ll be cancelling it and making a template in Canva to use instead.
- Canva: I used Canva for when I wanted to create a carousel. You can also post directly to your Instagram account (but not when it’s a carousel, ugh). For that I had to use my final tool.
- Meta Business Suite: This is a free tool from Meta that lets you post and schedule content to your Instagram and Facebook business pages and view all their stats. You can even post stories from this now, but I didn’t experiment with that.
Chapter 10: What’s Next?
I’ve really been wanting to try YouTube as a different way of making long form content so I’m going to begin a 3 month experiment on their too. I already have a decent (and steadily growing) following over there: @bootcampideas1
As I mentioned when it came to creating reels, I don’t love the idea of making video, but making videos that teach something that people can refer back to for years, that’s appealing to me.
I’m just mapping out what the challenge will look like eg. How often will I post? What topics will I cover? etc.
I also want to do the challenge in such a way that you, a locally based trainer, can also use YouTube to help more customers and clients find you. If you train clients who are over 50, they spend a lot of time on YouTube so it could be perfect for you.
I’ll be sure to include you with updates as I go along. Make sure you’re on my email newsletter to receive them.
Chapter 11: My Final Thoughts
I debated writing this experiment summary as I knew it would be epic and take a lot of time, but I’m incredible grateful that I did.
Running a business is all about working out what works for you. And the only way to do that is to experiment. But if we experiment without taking the time to learn and assess those experiments, we don’t gain any certainty. We just keep ping ponging around from thing to thing.
Writing this review has helped me gain clarity around my social media use.
Something I struggled with for years. I now know where it fits into my business and life, as a quick way to connect and get feedback rather than as a major marketing platform.
If this inspires you to do your own marketing experiment, I’d love to hear about it. Shoot me an email or leave a comment below.
And don’t forget to follow Bootcamp Ideas on YouTube so you catch all my awesome videos when they arrive.



Ahhh this was good for me to read! I have been beating myself up because of my perceived ‘lack’ of consistency on social media platforms.
My posts are erratic, they take too long and I obsess over the engagement stats.
I actually am the opposite of you- I like creating reels a lot. I’m just an overthinker and spend insanely too much time on one- so I often only post once a week.
This gives me stuff to think about- I want to learn how to use tools, but I dont want to use a content generator (it’s a HUGE peeve of mine)
Thanks for the detailed summary!
Thanks for reading Kara π
Tools do help, but I do find Instagram still often requires you needing to use it directly to get the most out of it.
One thing you might consider is reusing content to post more frequently. Only a fraction of your followers see each post, so reusing a reel from 6-12 months ago with a new caption will help those who missed it the first time.
I loved this article! I’ve been running a bootcamp for several years now and have a steady following, but I’ve also been trying to figure out how to engage more potential bootcampers on instagram and it’s been very frustrating. I haven’t been consistent with posting and haven’t been using the scheduling tools at all. I know that if I commit to a schedule I would get much better results. This was certainly worth the read. I will make sure to follow your account on IG.
Thanks Troy! I hoped this article would be helpful to even just 1 or 2 people.
I just saw your IG account. You’ve got some great stuff! If I can offer some feedback, I feel like a few photos or reels of your bootcamps might help people see that you run a bootcamp. At the moment it’s not very clear because it’s mostly just videos of you (which is also good! A bit of both would help maybe?)
This was great information. As a Fitness Trainer, I am always looking at ways to grow my business and spread the positive word about fitness and nutrition. Thanks for taking the time to share this with all of us.
You’re very welcome Louie. I’m glad you found it helpful!